Real Skill packageSource verifiedClawHub registry

Product Judgment

先判断需求,再写 PRD。 我把《俞军产品方法论》中的核心产品判断方法,转化成了 Agent 可以直接执行的需求评审流程。 核心是回答一个问题:这个需求到底值不值得做? 这是一个 Agent Skill(SKILL.md),供产品经理和 AI Agent 在写 PRD 之前评审需求或产品想法;通过 npx skills add 安装,可用于 Claude Code、Codex 或其他支持 Skill 的 Agent 工作流。

Identity and source

Publisher attributionHarlandregistry owner unverified by skillvetai
Functional categoryAgent Engineering, Security & Governanceautomatically inferred · 60% rule confidence
Package forminstruction with code12 recorded files
Canonical sourceClawHub registryclawhub:longfellow1:product-judgment-skill
Open canonical source ↗

Platform declarations

These states come from the source or distribution context. None of the entries below are SkillVetAI compatibility test results.

OpenClawnative officialProvenance: registry distribution

Independent structural checks

These checks parse the fixed package against dated platform rules. They do not execute the Skill or verify task behavior.

Claude Codepasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+claude-code-docs-2026-08-13 · 10/30/2026.claude/skills/product-judgment

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

OpenAI Codexpasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+codex-docs-2026-08-13 · 10/30/2026.agents/skills/product-judgment

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

OpenClawpasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+openclaw-docs-2026-08-13 · 10/30/2026skills/product-judgment

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

Installation and inspection

This command is recorded from the source ecosystem and resolves the registry's latest release. The fixed release shown on this page should be inspected before adoption.

clawhub install @longfellow1/product-judgment-skill
clawhub inspect @longfellow1/product-judgment-skill --version 0.1.0

Security evidence

SkillVetAI static result: no findings detected

This automated, non-executing scan is bound to this release hash. It is not a safety certification and may contain false positives or false negatives.

Status
completed
Coverage
full text content
Files
11 / 12 inspected as text
Checked
10/30/2026, 6:05:09 PM
Scanner
0.1.3
Policy
1.0.3
4 inferred permission indicators
  • shell execution — automatically inferred
  • network access — automatically inferred
  • filesystem read — automatically inferred
  • filesystem write — automatically inferred
2 dependency and API indicators
  • api: clawhub.ai
  • api: github.com
External clawhub result: clean

This is registry-supplied evidence for the recorded release, not an independent SkillVetAI scan. Check the canonical source for the full report, scanner versions, scope, and current moderation state.

Evidence checked
10/30/2026, 6:01:01 AM
Release binding
Matches this record
  • vt: clean
  • skillspector: suspicious
  • llm: clean

Recorded files

The catalog stores hashes and an inventory summary for change detection. It does not republish the package contents.

Package content hashsha256:3a8263e83ea3a7c496eaf67c83cd0cc7d2edf99b8fbacf2808899805cacb28e8
Show up to 12 recorded paths
  • assets/hero.webp
  • examples/ai-meeting-assistant.md
  • examples/car-ai-assistant.md
  • examples/competitor-feature.md
  • references/fake-demand-patterns.md
  • references/user-value-equation.md
  • references/yu-jun-methodology.md
  • scripts/demand-check.py
  • skill-card.md
  • SKILL.md
  • templates/CLAUDE.md
  • templates/JUDGMENT.md

Source changelog

Introduces Product Judgment Skill 0.1.0 for evaluating product demands before PRDs or engineering commitments. - Requires anchoring the review in the real user, their specific problem moment, and how they solve it today. - Defines three modes: Quick Judgment, Formal Review, and Direction Setting. - Uses a three-strike protocol for judgments and provides action or direction guidance based on the review.